2. Malverne

The next safest small town on our list is Malverne. Located in Long Island’s Nassau County, this small village boasts a population of only about 8,000.

This place is especially preferred by residents who work in NYC but still want a small-town lifestyle and vibe. It’s widely known for its lovely appeal, with charming residential houses, quaint downtown restaurants and shops, as well as beautiful recreational parks and facilities.

With a property crime rate of 1.2 and a violent crime rate of just 0.2, Malvern is one of the safest small towns to live in, especially if you want to experience the hustle and bustle of a big city, but just a bit!